AI Search Tool Rank
All posts
By AI Search Tool Rank TeamAI citationsbrand accuracycitation analyticssource correction

AI is citing wrong information about my brand: how to fix the source

When an AI answer gets your brand wrong and cites a page for it, the page is what you fix. Three cases (your stale page, a wrong third-party page, a correct page misread) and the fix for each.

When AI is citing wrong information about your brand, you're in a better spot than the brand that gets a wrong answer with no footnote. You have a trail. The engine pointed at a page, and you can change that page, ask someone to change it, or give the engine a better one. You can't do any of that to the model itself.

The catch is that "the source is wrong" covers three different situations, and each needs a different fix. Spend a week emailing a review site about a wrong price and you'll feel silly when the cited page turns out to be your own two-year-old launch post.

This post is about the cited page. If you haven't worked out what kind of mistake you're dealing with yet (outdated, conflated with another company, invented), start with AI makes mistakes about my brand. For the end-to-end audit, see how to fact-check what AI is saying about your brand.

Examples below use a made-up company, Acme Analytics.

Read the citation before you do anything

Open the cited URL and find the sentence the answer leaned on. Four things decide which case you're in:

  1. Whose domain is it, yours or someone else's?
  2. Does the page say the wrong thing at all? Sometimes it doesn't.
  3. When was it last updated?
  4. How many prompts and engines cite it? One response is a nuisance. Forty responses across three engines is a priority.

Answer the first two and you know your case.

Case 1: the engine cites your own stale page

This is the most common case and the cheapest one to fix. Typical culprits: a launch post announcing a plan you later retired, which still ranks for "Acme pricing". A help article describing the old onboarding flow. A landing page for a discontinued product that's still live and still in the sitemap. A translated pricing page nobody updated when the English one changed.

Start by updating or retiring the page. If it still has a job, correct the fact and add a visible updated date. If it doesn't, redirect it to the page that states the current fact, so crawlers and old links land somewhere correct.

Then look for siblings. A stale fact is rarely on one page, so search the whole site, including PDFs, docs, the changelog and every language version.

Make the current page the obvious answer. If the stale page ranked because it was the only one with a clear price in a sentence, the current pricing page needs that sentence too. And check that AI crawlers can fetch the new version: if a bot gets blocked or keeps hitting errors, the engine goes on reading its old copy.

Then wait for a re-crawl and watch whether the citations move to the corrected page. That can take weeks, so judge it on the trend.

Case 2: it cites a third-party page that's wrong

Here the wrong fact lives on someone else's site. Common versions:

  • A directory or review listing (G2, Capterra or a Trustpilot-style profile) with an old price, an old category or a feature list from years ago.
  • A competitor's comparison page that says Acme lacks a feature it has had since 2024.
  • An old Reddit thread about a bug Acme fixed long ago.
  • A roundup article that was accurate when published and never revised.

What you can do depends on how much control you have.

Listings are usually the fastest. If you can claim the profile, claim it and update it. If you can't, most listing sites have a correction route for vendors.

Editorial pages need a specific, polite request. Send the author the exact sentence, the correct fact, and a URL on your own site that proves it. "Your article is wrong" gets ignored. "Paragraph three says Acme starts at $49; the current entry price is on this page" gets fixed more often than you'd expect.

Competitor comparison pages may never be corrected. Publish your own comparison page for the same query, state the facts fairly, and give the engine a better source to choose.

Old forum threads can't be edited. If the community allows it, post a disclosed reply with the current fact. Either way, make sure a newer, clearer source exists for the same question.

In every version of case 2, also publish the correct fact on your own site in the shape the wrong page used. If a roundup's pricing table is what gets cited, your pricing page needs an equally clear table.

Case 3: the cited page is right, and the answer is still wrong

Sometimes you open the cited page and it states the correct fact. The engine misread it, or blended it with a second source in the same answer.

Two hypothetical examples. Acme's pricing page says "Team costs $40 a month per workspace", and the answer says "$40 per user". Or an answer cites Acme's pricing page next to a competitor's, and attaches the competitor's prompt limit to Acme's plan.

Pages get misread for ordinary reasons. The fact is stated far from the product name. It sits in an image, or in a tab that only renders with JavaScript, so the crawler never received it as text. One page covers three products with similar names. A table has no labels that make sense out of context.

The fix is to make the page hard to misread. Put the fact near the top in a full sentence that names the product, such as "Acme Team costs $40 a month per workspace, not per user." Make sure the important facts are in the HTML a crawler receives. Split pages that try to cover several products. If the problem is blending, look at the other source sitting next to yours in the answer. If that page is wrong, you're back in case 2.

Tracing and fixing sources with Promptwatch

Doing this by hand works for a handful of answers. It stops working once you need every page cited for every prompt about you, across engines, every day, plus proof that a fix took. Promptwatch is the tool we'd use for that, because it connects the cited page to your own pages and to the crawler logs that show whether an engine has seen your correction.

Finding the bad source

Citation analytics has three tabs, All Citations, URL Positions and Citation Trends, each filterable by monitor. Citation search finds a specific URL or domain, with competitor domains highlighted, so a rival's comparison page stands out in the list. Citation Trends classifies every citation into 20 source types, including a Directory type for G2, Capterra and Trustpilot-style listing and review sites. Filter by it and you can see how much of your citation footprint comes from listings, which is where stale prices tend to sit.

On URL Positions, the Agent Chat side panel can point out cited domains that belong to competitors you don't track yet, and it asks before adding one.

Telling case 1 from case 2

If the cited URL is on your domain, you're in case 1, and Fact Check helps find the siblings. You mark the claim Inaccurate, and Fact Check reads the pages crawled from your site for any that state it or the opposite, with quotes and a recommended next step. That turns "search the whole site" into a list of URLs. Fact Check is on Business ($579 a month), Agency Scale ($799 a month) and Enterprise, and each run uses Agent Credits with an estimate shown before it runs.

If the cited URL is someone else's, put it in Page Tracker. Page Tracker follows any URL, yours or a third party's, and shows the responses and prompts that cite it. You learn how much the page matters before you spend time on outreach, and later whether it fades after a correction.

Offsite mentions cover a related case: third-party pages that name your brand without linking to you, ranked as opportunities. When one of those carries the wrong fact, the correction request is also a good moment to ask for the link.

Fixing your own pages

Content Refresh suggests diff-style updates to existing pages, so you can see exactly which sentences change. Review each suggestion against your source of truth before accepting it, especially anything with a number in it. Our guide to content refresh for pages AI stopped citing walks through that editing process step by step.

Confirming the fix was picked up

A corrected page only helps once an engine has fetched it, and that's what crawler data shows. Agent Analytics, which needs crawler logs (Professional and up), records IP-verified visits from bots such as GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ChatGPT-User and PerplexityBot, with error tracking. Its crawl-to-citation path gives a citation rate per page, which tells an access problem from a content problem. A corrected page that is crawled but still rarely cited has a content problem. One that isn't being crawled at all has an access problem.

Since November 4, 2026, each page in your sitemap also has its own tabs. The AI Visibility tab shows that one URL's citation rate and position over time, with the prompts and responses that cite it. The Content tab shows the page as it was crawled and how much changed between the last two audits, which is handy for case 3: you see the text the crawler got, not the version in your CMS. The Agent Analytics tab shows citation visits, crawler visits and the crawler logs for that URL.

Read them in order after a fix. The Content tab should show your edit. The Agent Analytics tab should then show a new crawl. The AI Visibility tab should, over the following weeks, show the citation rate holding or rising while the wrong claim fades from the responses.

Which trackers can catch a bad source

Spotting that an answer is wrong is the easy part. Finding the cited page, telling whose it is, and confirming a fix was re-crawled take citation data and crawler data in the same place.

  • Promptwatch covers the whole path: citations by page, domain and source type, Page Tracker for third-party URLs, Fact Check against your own pages on Business and up, and per-URL crawler logs from Professional.
  • AthenaHQ turns gaps into on-page and off-page actions through its Action Center, and lists the Athena Citation Engine on Enterprise. Our listing records no Reddit monitoring or crawler analytics.
  • Scrunch AI includes AI agent and bot traffic reporting on Core ($250 a month). Its Enterprise AXP serves AI-optimized versions of pages to crawlers, which is relevant to case 3. Our listing notes that its data refreshes weekly.
  • Profound offers citation share and answer-level analytics within a broader enterprise marketing-agent product on custom pricing.

Your next step

Pick one wrong answer that cites a page, the one that comes up most often in your own testing. Book a Promptwatch demo and ask to see that answer traced from the cited URL through Page Tracker and Fact Check to the crawler logs for the page you'd fix. If the trail ends on your own site, you'll know the fix is yours. If it ends on someone else's, you'll know which page to chase.