AI makes mistakes about my brand: what to do about each kind
Wrong AI answers about a brand come in five kinds, and each has its own cause. How to tell outdated, conflated, invented, mispositioned and unflattering claims apart, and the fix for each.
"AI makes mistakes about my brand" is usually said after someone has spent an afternoon arguing with ChatGPT. The arguing doesn't help. What helps is noticing that brand mistakes come in a handful of distinct kinds, and each kind has its own cause and its own fix. A wrong price and a mix-up with a similarly named company look the same in a screenshot. Once you go looking for the cause, they have almost nothing in common.
This post sorts brand mistakes into five types and gives the fix path for each. Then it covers how to do the sorting across hundreds of answers instead of one screenshot at a time. If you want the full audit method first (prompt set, engines, re-testing), read our guide on how to fact-check what AI is saying about your brand. This one assumes a wrong answer is already in front of you.
All examples below use a made-up company, Acme Analytics.
Before you sort anything, write down what is true
You can't classify a mistake without a reference. Keep a short source-of-truth document: current plans and prices, what each plan includes, the integrations you support, the ones you don't, who the product is for, and the basic company facts. Next to each line, put the URL on your site that states it.
If no page states a fact, write that down too. A missing page is the cause of one of the five types.
Type 1: outdated
The claim was true once. ChatGPT says Acme's Starter plan costs $49 a month, but Acme retired Starter last spring. Gemini mentions an onboarding fee that was dropped a year ago.
You recognize this type because the claim matches an older version of you. You can usually name the month it stopped being true.
It almost always comes from an old page that still exists. Often that page is yours: a replaced pricing page that was never redirected, a launch post announcing the old plan, a help article nobody touched, a PDF price sheet. Sometimes it's a review or directory listing written before the change.
The fix starts on your own site, because those pages are the ones you control. Search for the old fact, then update or redirect every page that still carries it. Put a visible "last updated" date on the current pricing page and say the change in words: "Acme retired the Starter plan in March. The entry plan is now Team." If the wrong answers cite someone else's page, you have a source problem, and our companion post on AI citing wrong information about your brand covers that case in detail.
Type 2: conflated
Here the engine merges you with someone else. Acme Analytics gets credited with the founding year and headquarters of Acme Labs, an unrelated company. Or a feature your closest rival sells turns up in your description.
The tell is that the wrong fact is true of another company. Search the claim along with a couple of similar names and you'll often find the source of the mix-up in a few minutes.
The cause is weak identity signals. If your pages never say plainly who you are, where you're based and what you make, the engine has to guess, and it guesses from whichever similar name has more coverage. Comparison tables that list several vendors side by side can blur the line as well.
Fix it by making the distinction explicit on your own site. An about page that states the facts in full sentences. The same company name everywhere, including profiles and listings. Organization markup that links to your official profiles. If one company causes most of the confusion, a single line such as "Acme Analytics is not affiliated with Acme Labs" in your FAQ is worth adding. It gives the engine a sentence it can quote.
Check your own tracking too. If your monitoring tool counts Acme Labs mentions as yours, the confusion leaks into your own numbers.
Type 3: invented
The claim is true of nobody. An integration you never built, a mobile app you don't have, a lifetime deal that never existed. This is the type most people mean when they say "hallucination".
You recognize it when you search your site and the cited sources and find no page that says it.
Usually the cause is a gap. Buyers ask "does Acme integrate with Salesforce?", your site never answers, and the engine fills the silence with a plausible yes. Occasionally a third-party article made the error first and the engine repeated it, which makes it a source problem again.
The fix is to answer the question in writing. Keep an integrations page that lists what you support and, for the integrations people commonly ask about, what you don't. Add FAQ entries for the "does it have X" questions. Saying no on your own site feels strange. Still, "Acme has no native mobile app; the web app works in mobile browsers" is a better thing for an engine to find than silence.
Query fan-outs, the sub-searches an engine runs before answering, are the best clue here. They show which question your site failed to answer.
Type 4: wrong audience or positioning
Every fact is roughly right and the picture is still wrong. AI calls Acme "an enterprise analytics suite" when most customers are five-person teams. Or it recommends Acme for a use case you dropped two years ago. These answers rarely look like errors, which is why they stick around.
Line by line, the answer is accurate. A buyer reading it would still come away with the wrong impression. Persona prompts make this visible: ask the same question as a solo founder and as an IT director and compare what each one gets back.
The cause is that the content about you leans one way. If your case studies are all large companies and the reviews that rank were written by enterprise buyers, the engine summarizes what it sees.
This one is a content program. Publish pages for the audience you want, such as use-case pages, a plain explanation of pricing for small teams, and comparison pages that say who you're best for. Try to get covered in the places that audience reads. Expect it to move slower than the other four.
Type 5: true but unflattering
"Support can be slow to respond." "Reporting is limited." Sometimes the claim is correct, or was correct recently, and it comes from real reviews and forum threads.
You recognize it when you check it against your source of truth and can't honestly mark it wrong.
Don't treat this as a content problem. A page that contradicts a true complaint won't hold up, because the reviews are still out there and the engine will keep finding them. Take the claim to the product or support team instead. Once the issue is fixed in the product, the claim becomes Type 1, outdated, and you can publish the change: a changelog entry, a support page with the new response times, a reply in the thread where the complaint lives.
A quick way to sort a claim
| Question to ask | If the answer is yes | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Was it true of you at some point? | Find and fix the old page | Outdated |
| Is it true of a different company? | Strengthen identity signals | Conflated |
| Is it true of nobody? | Answer the question on your site | Invented |
| Are the facts right but the picture wrong? | Build content for the right audience | Positioning |
| Is it true right now? | Fix the product, then publish the change | Unflattering |
Doing this at scale with Promptwatch
Sorting five claims by hand takes an afternoon. Sorting every claim across a few hundred tracked responses each week is not something a team keeps up for long. The time goes on two steps: finding the claims inside long answers, and checking which of your pages say them. Those are the two steps Promptwatch automates, which is why it's the tool we'd use for this job.
Brand Narrative, on every plan, pulls the individual claims AI makes about you and your competitors out of your tracked responses. Repeats are grouped, so "Acme starts at $49" across thirty answers becomes one row with a count and the list of models that say it. Each claim is filed under a theme such as Pricing, Features, Support or Reputation and scored positive, neutral, negative or mixed. Each theme gets a 0 to 100 score you can compare with competitors.
For the taxonomy above, the model column is a useful first clue. A claim that only one or two engines repeat points you at the sources those engines cite. A claim every model repeats is worth checking on your own site first.
Fact Check is the step that separates Type 1 from Type 3. You mark a claim Accurate or Inaccurate, and Fact Check reads the pages crawled from your site to find the ones that state the claim or the opposite, with quotes and a recommended next step. Three outcomes are possible. It finds your old pricing page repeating the retired plan, so the mistake is outdated and the fix is yours to make. It finds nothing, so the claim is invented or coming from off your site, and the citations tell you which. Or it finds a page that clearly states the correct fact, which means your site is fine and the engine is reading something else.
Fact Check is on Business ($579 a month), Agency Scale ($799 a month) and Enterprise. Each run uses Agent Credits, and you see the estimate before it runs.
The accuracy score, added in the November 4, 2026 changelog, rolls those checks into one number: the share of your checked mentions that are accurate, shown overall and as a heatmap per model and theme. A claim you marked counts as you marked it; otherwise the latest completed check decides. Inconclusive and unchecked claims are left out. Keep that in mind when you report the score upward. A high score over ten checked claims says those ten are fine, not that everything AI says about you is.
The other types lean on other parts of the same workspace. For conflation, the Brand Book holds analysis instructions that decide what counts as a mention, and brand aliases catch your own name variants, so another company's mentions stay out of your data. For invented claims, query fan-outs per model show the exact sub-queries behind a response, and content gap analysis gives each topic a coverage score.
Positioning problems show up best with personas. Run the same prompts as different buyers, and Persona Insights compares each persona with the general audience and points out the biggest gap. For true-but-unflattering claims, the theme comparison against competitors tells you whether the complaint is yours alone, and the Action Board lets you assign it to whoever owns the product fix.
If you're on Essential or Professional, you still get the claim list from Brand Narrative. Do the "which of my pages says this" step with a site search instead of Fact Check. It's slower, but for a short list it works. Our walkthrough of seeing AI claims claim by claim has a weekly routine for exactly that setup.
Which trackers can catch these mistakes
Most AI visibility tools were built to answer "were we mentioned?" Catching a mistake takes the response text broken into claims. Finding the cause takes a link from the claim to a page.
- Promptwatch extracts claims on every plan and checks them against your crawled pages on Business, Agency Scale and Enterprise, with citation and crawler data to trace what's left.
- AthenaHQ is listed in our catalog with a unified GEO score that includes sentiment analysis, and an Action Center that turns gaps into assignable tasks. Starter is $295 a month. Our listing doesn't document claim extraction or a check against your own pages.
- Scrunch AI Core ($250 a month) includes sentiment analysis, site audits and recommendations across four LLMs. Our listing doesn't document claim-level checks.
- Profound offers citation share and answer-level analytics inside an enterprise marketing-agent platform on custom pricing. Claim-level checks aren't documented in our listing either.
"Not documented" isn't the same as "impossible". If one of these is already on your shortlist, ask for a demo that takes one wrong claim and traces it to a page. For a wider ranking built around this job, see our roundup of the best GEO tools for correcting what AI says about your brand.
Your next step
Take the three wrong claims that bother you most and sort them with the table above. If two of them turn out to be outdated or invented, the fix is probably on your own site, and Fact Check will find the page faster than you can. Start Promptwatch's 7-day free trial on Business, the first brand plan that includes Fact Check, and run it on those three claims.