AI Search Tool Rank
All posts
By AI Search Tool Rank Teamathenahqmigrationswitching platformsbloomreachgeo

Migrating from AthenaHQ to another AI visibility platform: a ranked checklist

Planning to move off AthenaHQ after the Bloomreach deal? A seven-step migration checklist, the destinations ranked by how cleanly an AthenaHQ setup moves into them, and why Promptwatch is the one to trial first.

Four days after Bloomreach announced it had bought AthenaHQ, the question in our inbox has moved on from "what does the deal mean" to "how do we actually leave". We covered the first question, and ranked the alternatives, in our post on the acquisition. This one is the practical follow-up: a step-by-step migration checklist, plus a ranking of where an AthenaHQ setup moves most cleanly.

AthenaHQ facts below come from our catalog entry, which records its plans page as read on October 24 and rechecked on November 16, 2026. Facts about other tools come from their catalog entries on this site. Promptwatch facts come from its own documentation and pricing page.

AthenaHQ homepage with a "New: AthenaHQ is now part of Bloomreach" banner above the headline "Become the Brand AI Trusts" and a free audit email form AthenaHQ's homepage on November 16, 2026.

First, is leaving the right call?

Not for everyone. AthenaHQ sits at #2 on our leaderboard for a reason: its Action Center turns visibility gaps into assignable tasks, and plenty of teams work that queue every day. AthenaHQ also told customers that accounts, contracts and support stay as they are, so nobody is being forced out this quarter.

The case for moving rests on four things, and you need at least one of them to apply to you:

  • The roadmap. Bloomreach sells ecommerce personalization, and the first joint products are due in early 2027. No published source says whether AthenaHQ keeps standalone plans and pricing after that. If you aren't a retailer, that is a fair reason to test something else before renewal.
  • Credits. Starter is $295 a month for 3,600 credits, and one credit is one AI response. Thirty prompts on four engines, run daily, uses the whole allowance.
  • Markets. Starter is country-level, and our entry records it as single-country. Multi-region, multi-language and persona targeting sit on Enterprise.
  • Missing layers. Our entry lists no AI crawler-log product and no Reddit monitoring.

If none of these bother you, stay and look again when the 2027 packaging is public.

The migration checklist, in order

Order matters more than speed. Every step below protects something you'd otherwise lose.

  1. Write down your reason for leaving. "Credits run out" points to a different destination than "we need crawler logs". Keep it next to the shortlist.
  2. Export everything you own. AthenaHQ's plans page listed CSV export on Starter when it was read on November 16. Pull prompts, topics, competitors, countries and as many months of responses as the export allows. No platform in our catalog documents importing another vendor's history, so the export is your only record.
  3. Freeze the prompt set. Rebuild the same prompts, in the same country and language, with the same competitors. Improve the set later. If you change the prompts and the tool in the same month, you can't tell which one moved the numbers.
  4. Match the engines. Pick the same engines you tracked in AthenaHQ for the headline view. Track any new engines as a separate line until they have a few months of history.
  5. Run both tools for two to four weeks. Don't compare headline scores, since every vendor defines visibility differently. Compare direction and competitor order. If the same prompts flip and the same rivals rise, the new tool is reading the same reality.
  6. Re-baseline in writing. Tell stakeholders the trend line restarts on the switch date, and mark it on every chart.
  7. Cancel last, at renewal, after the new numbers have been stable for a few weeks.

Where to move, ranked by migration fit

Our main leaderboard ranks tools overall. This ranking asks a narrower question: how cleanly does an AthenaHQ setup move into the tool, and does the move fix the reasons people leave?

RankToolEntry plan (catalog)Volume at entryMarkets at entryTrial
BaselineAthenaHQStarter $295/mo3,600 credits (1 per response)Country-levelFree Essential tier, 300 credits
1PromptwatchEssential $95/mo50 prompts, 6,000 responsesCountry-level; state and city on Business7 days on monthly billing
2Scrunch AICore $250/mo125 prompts, 5,000 responses, 4 LLMsNot statedNot stated
3Goodie AICore $295/mo110 prompts, 5 modelsTwo countriesConflicting public info
4GaugeGrowth $599/mo600 prompts, 54,000 answers, 3 platformsOne locationNone shown
5ProfoundEnterprise, customTrial: 50 prompts daily for 7 daysNot stated7-day trial

1. Promptwatch

Promptwatch is the destination we'd trial first, because it handles the mechanics of the move and the reasons for it.

On the mechanics: a 200-prompt AthenaHQ list doesn't need retyping. Promptwatch's REST API and hosted MCP server both create prompts in bulk, and a project can be set up in a single API call. Topics, tags and prompt types (Organic, Brand Specific, Competitor Comparison) let you rebuild AthenaHQ's topic structure, and brand aliases plus Brand Book analysis instructions carry over your rules for what counts as a mention. During the parallel run, the responses export lists every brand named in each answer with its position, so you can check the two tools prompt by prompt.

Promptwatch prompt tracking page headed "Track prompts that get citations and clicks", with a product illustration of a prompts view listing top competitors and a visibility-by-prompt-type chart

On the reasons: plans are set by prompts and responses, not credits that drain per engine. Essential is $95 a month for 6,000 responses, Professional $245 for 18,000, Business $579 for 42,000. Country-level tracking is on every plan, and state and city tracking start on Business, so a multi-market brand doesn't need an enterprise contract to track several regions. Agent Analytics adds IP-verified AI crawler logs from Professional, with a citation rate per page that separates an access problem from a content problem.

Promptwatch Agent Analytics page headed "Analytics for AI agents", with tabs for crawler logs, AI traffic and crawl discovery

If AthenaHQ's Action Center was the part you liked, Promptwatch's Action Board is the equivalent: a prioritized to-do list, with a Discovery agent that suggests up to five evidence-backed actions per run.

2. Scrunch AI

Scrunch AI is a fair second, with one caveat for anyone leaving because of the acquisition: Sitecore bought Scrunch in June 2026, so the roadmap question follows you. Core covers four LLMs and our entry notes weekly refresh, so check both against your AthenaHQ setup before you freeze the prompt set.

3. Goodie AI

Goodie AI Core matches AthenaHQ Starter at $295 and adds a second country, which helps a two-market brand. Five models on Core may be fewer than you tracked.

4. Gauge

Gauge gives the most daily volume, but Growth covers three platforms and one location. It fits a team that tracked a narrow engine set in one market.

5. Profound

Profound is sold as an enterprise marketing-agent program, at about $40k a year by our earlier estimate. It's a move up market, not a like-for-like replacement for a $295 plan.

Mistakes to avoid in a tool switch

  • Cancelling first. AthenaHQ says nothing changes with your account, so there's no reason to rush.
  • Reporting the score gap as a result. A gap between two vendors' scores is a difference in definitions, not a gain or a loss.
  • Connecting crawler logs late. Crawl history starts on the day you connect it. Do it on day one of the trial.

Our pick

Start a Promptwatch trial on monthly billing (seven days, free, on every self-serve plan), load your exported AthenaHQ prompt set through the API, connect crawler logs on the first day, and run the parallel weeks. If you'd rather see a first read before creating an account, the free AI Visibility Report scans ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity for your site.