AI Search Tool Rank
All posts
By AI Search Tool Rank Teamai rank trackersfeature comparisonai search visibility

AI rank tracker compared: a feature matrix of 7 trackers

AI rank tracker compared feature by feature: engines, position, share of voice, citations, crawler logs, attribution and cadence across seven tools, gaps marked.

Two AI rank trackers can both say "tracks ChatGPT" and still measure very different things. One checks the live ChatGPT interface every day in five countries. The other asks a model through an API once a week. Both tick the same box on a pricing page.

So this comparison works capability by capability. The rows are the things a tracker can measure or do. The columns are seven trackers, in our ranking order. Every cell comes from our catalog entry for that tool or, for Promptwatch, from its own published documentation. When a vendor doesn't publish something, the cell says "Not stated". That doesn't mean the feature is missing. It means you should ask before you buy.

The matrix, part 1: what gets measured

CapabilityPromptwatchAthenaHQScrunch AIProfoundAhrefs Brand RadarSE RankingLLMrefs
Entry price$95/moFree; $295/mo$250/moCustomWith paid AhrefsEUR 109 + EUR 79Free; $79/mo (unconfirmed)
Engines on entry planAny supported11 models43 (trial)6, plus Claude on Custom Prompts3All listed engines
Live UI vs API labeledYesNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedNot stated
Visibility score0 to 100GEO scoreNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedNot stated
Share of voiceYesNot statedBenchmarkingCitation shareMention shareCompetitor researchYes
Position in answerYesNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedAverage position
SentimentYesYesYesNot statedNot statedYesNo
Prompt researchPrompt VolumesNot statedNot statedPrompt Volumes496M-prompt indexNot statedKeyword fan-outs

The matrix, part 2: diagnosis and operations

CapabilityPromptwatchAthenaHQScrunch AIProfoundAhrefs Brand RadarSE RankingLLMrefs
Citation analyticsPages, domains, socialEnterprise onlyNot statedCitation shareSources, YouTube, RedditIn developmentCited URLs
AI crawler logsIP-verified, from $245Not publishedBot traffic reportsNamed, depth not statedCrawler activityNot publishedNot published
AI traffic and conversionsEvery planGA4, Shopify, WebflowNot statedNot statedNot statedNot statedNot stated
CadenceDaily; hourly from $579Not statedNot statedDaily (trial)Daily quota; index monthlyDailyWeekly
LocationCountry; city from $579CountryNot statedNot statedNot statedNot stated50+ countries
Acting on resultsAction Board, Content AgentAction CenterRecommendationsMarketing agentsAhrefs toolsSEO suiteNot stated
API or MCPBoth, every planPaid add-onEnterpriseNot statedNot statedBothAPI
SeatsUnlimitedUnlimited users5Not statedNot stated1 on CoreUnlimited

A few notes on the cells. Promptwatch's "any supported" means every paid plan can track any of the engines it supports; it doesn't mean every model runs on every prompt. LLMrefs' $79 figure is from our earlier catalog entry and wasn't shown on the page we read on 24 October 2026. Semrush AI Toolkit isn't a column because we couldn't re-verify its pricing; our catalog lists it at $99 a month per domain for 25 prompts.

Engines and capture method

This is the row people check first and understand least. Count matters, but so does how the answer is collected. Promptwatch monitors ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, Amazon Alexa and Meta AI through their real interfaces, and tracks Claude, DeepSeek, Mistral, Grok and other models through APIs, labeled as such. That split matters because an API answer reflects training data, while the live interface includes the web search a buyer would trigger.

AthenaHQ lists 11 models on Starter, the highest number any vendor here puts on an entry plan, but our catalog doesn't say how answers are captured. Scrunch Core covers four (ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Copilot), and SE Ranking covers three (AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT). If your buyers use Gemini or Copilot, check those columns before anything else.

Position, share of voice and the visibility score

These three numbers answer different questions. Share of voice says how much of the conversation you own across all brands mentioned. Position says how early you appear when you do appear. A visibility score rolls presence and prominence into one trend line.

Only Promptwatch publishes all three, plus a definition: its Visibility Score weighs placement, share of attention and depth, and a response that skips your brand counts as zero. LLMrefs reports share of voice and average position, which is the classic rank tracker model applied to AI. AthenaHQ has its own GEO score. Most others publish a share or mention metric without a position. If a tool shows only mentions, you can see that you appear but not whether you are the first recommendation or the fifth.

Citations

Citations explain rankings. When an engine names a competitor, the cited sources usually show why: a review site, a Reddit thread, a comparison page you don't have. Promptwatch reports citations by page and domain, with Reddit, YouTube, LinkedIn and Instagram reports, a Page Tracker for specific URLs, and offsite mentions where you're named without a link. Ahrefs Brand Radar reports cited sources including YouTube and Reddit. LLMrefs shows cited URLs. AthenaHQ keeps its Athena Citation Engine on Enterprise, and SE Ranking lists citation-level tracking as still in development.

Crawler logs

This is the row with the most "Not published" cells, and it is the one that separates a tracker from a diagnostic tool. Crawler logs show whether AI bots reach your pages at all. Promptwatch's Agent Analytics logs IP-verified bots such as GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ChatGPT-User, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot, and shows a citation rate per page. That tells an access problem (the bot never fetched the page) from a content problem (it fetched it and didn't cite it). It starts on Professional at $245 a month.

Scrunch reports AI agent and bot traffic, and Ahrefs reports AI crawler activity. Profound's site names Agent Analytics, but our catalog doesn't document how deep it goes. None of the three is documented with a crawl-to-citation view.

Traffic and conversions

A ranking that never reaches your site is a vanity number. Promptwatch's visitor analytics count AI-referred visits and conversions from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and others on every plan, installed by script, GTM template or WordPress plugin. AthenaHQ lists GA4, Shopify and Webflow revenue attribution. The rest don't state it.

Cadence and location

AI answers vary between runs, so cadence decides how much noise you average out. Promptwatch runs prompts daily, with every 12, 6 or 1 hours on Business. SE Ranking tracks prompts daily. Ahrefs Custom Prompts run on a daily quota of 5 to 20 depending on your Ahrefs plan, while its index is retested monthly. LLMrefs refreshes weekly, which is fine for trend lines and too slow to catch a sudden drop.

On location, Promptwatch tracks by country on every paid plan, by state and city from Business, and can pin a monitor to coordinates within a 20 m to 5 km radius. LLMrefs lists 50+ countries and 20+ languages. AthenaHQ's Starter is country-level.

Which tracker for which situation

You need one tool to track, diagnose and report: Promptwatch. It is the only column without a "Not stated" in the diagnosis rows.

You want a GEO score with assignable tasks and accept credit pricing: AthenaHQ, keeping in mind the Bloomreach acquisition announced on 16 November 2026.

You care mostly about ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews and Copilot at a fixed monthly price: Scrunch Core.

You are an enterprise buying marketing agents with tracking attached: Profound.

You already pay for Ahrefs or SE Ranking: start with their AI module and see whether the quotas and engines are enough.

You think in keywords and positions and want a low entry price: LLMrefs, with a weekly cadence. Otterly.AI, Peec AI and Searchable cover simple monitoring too, with fewer diagnostics.

If you want these capabilities weighted into a single number, our 2026 AI rank tracker scorecard does that. The method for running the tracking itself is in how to do AI rank tracking, our guide on how to measure your brand's AI search visibility covers the metrics in more depth, and the broader ranking is at what are the best AI rank trackers.

Our recommendation: most of the gaps in this matrix sit in citations, crawler logs and attribution, and that is where Promptwatch is strongest. If you want to see those rows filled with your own data, book a Promptwatch demo and ask them to show the crawl-to-citation view for one of your pages.